Page 1 of 4

Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 2:07 am
by Sidekick84
Hi guys,

Yes lately I have been looking at buying an FTO but due to recent events in my life (wife leaving me) I am now forced to buy a family car as I need a four door for my son.

My budget is around the 6k mark still and I would still love to get something sporty in an auto (would love something with manual options like the tiptronic or selespeed).

One car I have been looking at is a Alpha Romeo 156 in the auto selespeed but not sure about their reliability and ongoing expense. Otherwise I guess a ford or a Holden would suit, any suggestions?

Thanks guys appreciate any help as I am a little bummed out at the moment (mainly missing out on an FTO lol)

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 2:17 am
by spetz
The Alfa is a nice option but certainly reliability will be an issue.
For 6K I would suggest getting a Mitsubishi Verada. They're very comfortable and reliable, and for a 3.5L they are ok on fuel (expect around 12L/100km). You can get a "sporty" Magna VR-x in a manual if you want, alternatively all of the Veradas past the year 2000 have the tip shift autos. 2002 onwards got 5 speed gearboxes.
If fuel cost is a major concern, the N16 Nissan Pulsar is a great option managing around 8L/100km

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 3:27 am
by Daniel2019
Sorry to hear about the bad news mate.

Have you considered a little four door lancer?

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 3:33 am
by Taz
^

Mrs has a new late model lancer - its a tip and goes pretty hard - give an fto a run for its money in a manual, yet is surprisingly economical, i think our record is 700 odd km's of city driving on a single tank - being the new variable mivec its not half bad to drive. also 4 door with a bit of room, i recommend it if thats what youre after - very reliable (considering before she met me it went a good 150km without a major service and the ABS light on for about 30km (women :facepalm:)) and still runs strong :lol:

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 5:04 am
by spetz
A late model Lancer will not fall into the budget of 6K.

Lancers, Civics and Toyotas kept their value reasonably well, whereas the Pulsars seem to have depreciated more.
My friend has an N16 Pulsar auto and I was really surprised at how quiet, smooth and comfortable it was. I think definitely better than a same era Lancer

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 8:29 am
by Astron_Boy
Don't go Alfa unless you want to spend over your 6K budget.

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 8:45 am
by Sidekick84
Thanks everyone, I will keep an eye out on the cars mentioned, looking today around town but not liking my chances :cry: any commodore or falcon I should look for as there are most likely going to be a few of these in my price bracket. Plus what sort of km's should I be looking for or avoiding?

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 9:02 am
by Astron_Boy
As an alternate, a 318i 1.9L E36 is a decent purchase for a 4 door 'sporty' car.
Still has plenty of get up and go, reliable, and even in the highish kms, cheap for parts.

I'd buy one of those over a Commonwhore.

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 9:20 am
by Sidekick84
Just found this one...http://www.carsales.com.au/private/deta ... rt=default

Just worried about our driveway though might scrape...

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 9:25 am
by Astron_Boy
Yeah, not too bad.
Uncommon kit, very sought after.

Check the Magna forums, it may be a members car.

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 9:33 am
by spetz
If you don't like the bodykit, the Magna Sports is the same car (sports suspension, bit more power etc) but has no bodykit.

Keep in mind autos are less fuel economical, slower and less reliable

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 9:43 am
by dstocks
How old is your son. I had my son in the back of my FTO regularly before he turned 7. Even after that, they fit OK with the passengers seat forward. Just a thought

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 9:45 am
by Sidekick84
I wanted a manual before as a second car as I will need to learn to drive stick, that's why I thought it be best to get an auto. Would it be a pain to learn manual? do you think that is a better option?

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 9:46 am
by Astron_Boy
spetz wrote:Keep in mind autos are less reliable
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, I'm not going to make a debate.
But the common issue on the Magna forums isn't about bad gearboxes...

Let's leave it there. ;)

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 9:47 am
by Sidekick84
dstocks wrote:How old is your son. I had my son in the back of my FTO regularly before he turned 7. Even after that, they fit OK with the passengers seat forward. Just a thought
He is 3yrs old

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 9:51 am
by Sidekick84

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 10:16 am
by dstocks
They have an EXTREMELY bad reputation. Everything ive heard points towards gutless piece of poo.

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 10:18 am
by Daniel2019
Learning to drive manual isnt hard at all mate. Ive driven a manual car maybe 5 or 6 times now and Id be more than confident in driving pretty much anywhere in one. Sure, for the first couple of days your clutch might hate you but meh!

In terms of the FTO - I think it may be more of a safety concern rather than a convenience concern.

As for the 4 door lancer, you can pick up a decent one for $5k. 4 door ones seem to be slightly less common but still around.

Dont buy a PT cruiser.

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 10:30 am
by spetz
Sidekick84 wrote:I wanted a manual before as a second car as I will need to learn to drive stick, that's why I thought it be best to get an auto. Would it be a pain to learn manual? do you think that is a better option?
Why not have a driving lesson or two with a manual car and see how you find it. If you're into cars you should pick it up fairly quick.

Astron_Boy wrote:
spetz wrote:Keep in mind autos are less reliable
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm, I'm not going to make a debate.
But the common issue on the Magna forums isn't about bad gearboxes...

Let's leave it there. ;)
Autos are less reliable, and more importantly when they go wrong it costs a lot to repair. In a manual it's safer to replace with a second hand one (compared to auto) and the wear items cost less (eg, clutch Vs auto rebuild). Not to mention autos require costly oil flushes.

What is the common issue with Magnas? The auto transmission is amongst the top failures, and there are countless threads regarding this on aussiemagna.

Re: Need a family car urgently!

Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2013 10:39 am
by Daniel2019
spetz wrote:Not to mention autos require costly oil flushes.
How much do places charge for an auto transmission fluid change....?