Got minor defect notice, sigh
Moderators: IMC, Club Staff
- Valandis91
- Veteran Mechanic
- Posts: 1169
- jedwabna poszewka promocja
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2008 5:00 pm
- Location: Tasmania
- Contact:
Got minor defect notice, sigh
Last night went for a spirited run through the taroona bends on the way back a cop mustve been speeding through the bends for like 7 mins just to catch up to me even though i wasnt speeding. i got a bit sus cos this car was catching up fast behind me and been in awkward situations before. Turned out being a undercover cop.
He claimed he was doing 70km/h in the 60 zone just to keep up with me even though he was ages behind me so i dont how that works. wasnt using a speed gun or anything just his speedo....
pulled me over after a couple of mins. Gave me speeding fine for 10k's over being $110 fine a 2 demerit points. as a P1 Plater i only have 4 and this means i have to restart my p1 which i only have less than 3 months of left before i can go off my p's.
i was only doing 60 and he wouldve still been catching up to me so i have no idea how he got it. just guessed probably.
then gave me a defect notice for my exhaust being too loud.
Said he heard me going trhough and then coming back. i said my car sounds like its going faster than what it is. i get it all the time. but nothing.
so yeah what should i do now for both?
ive been driving around with thi8s exhaust for like 6 months in the city most the time and had lots of cops behind me and never been pulled over or nothing for it.
it really freakinmg frustrates me.
He claimed he was doing 70km/h in the 60 zone just to keep up with me even though he was ages behind me so i dont how that works. wasnt using a speed gun or anything just his speedo....
pulled me over after a couple of mins. Gave me speeding fine for 10k's over being $110 fine a 2 demerit points. as a P1 Plater i only have 4 and this means i have to restart my p1 which i only have less than 3 months of left before i can go off my p's.
i was only doing 60 and he wouldve still been catching up to me so i have no idea how he got it. just guessed probably.
then gave me a defect notice for my exhaust being too loud.
Said he heard me going trhough and then coming back. i said my car sounds like its going faster than what it is. i get it all the time. but nothing.
so yeah what should i do now for both?
ive been driving around with thi8s exhaust for like 6 months in the city most the time and had lots of cops behind me and never been pulled over or nothing for it.
it really freakinmg frustrates me.

- vipfto
- Forum Moderator
- Posts: 4154
- Joined: Mon Oct 29, 2007 5:00 pm
- Location: Adelaide
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
put a baffle plate in just to get the defect off
and just wear the fine $110 is bugger all pain about being longer on your P's but it could be worse
and just wear the fine $110 is bugger all pain about being longer on your P's but it could be worse
FTO GR-TURBO
172KW ATW @ 11PSI
172KW ATW @ 11PSI
- Valandis91
- Veteran Mechanic
- Posts: 1169
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2008 5:00 pm
- Location: Tasmania
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
whats a baffle plate?
but im only 2.5 motnhs away man and it kills me.
this is unfair as they have no hard evidence.
im sorry but im taking it too court without question
but im only 2.5 motnhs away man and it kills me.
this is unfair as they have no hard evidence.
im sorry but im taking it too court without question

- spency
- Mechanic
- Posts: 761
- Joined: Sun Mar 28, 2010 5:00 pm
- Location: Hobart
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
by the time you take it to court and fight it, you may be on your next stage.
you should only be dropped back to restart p2s (hopefully)
you should only be dropped back to restart p2s (hopefully)
- Bennoz
- National President
- Posts: 23678
- Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2005 6:00 pm
- Location: Sydney
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
How the hell does a cop 'know' when an exhaust is too loud? Is his ear the DB measuring device? No. You'll have to take it to court.
Same with the speeding. They can't follow you for a 1/4 mile while checking your speed on their speedo. Doesn't work like that any more, must be gun measured.
If you can afford the time off work & want to beat the system, take itt to court cause you'll get off both items. The cop was being a cock.
Same with the speeding. They can't follow you for a 1/4 mile while checking your speed on their speedo. Doesn't work like that any more, must be gun measured.
If you can afford the time off work & want to beat the system, take itt to court cause you'll get off both items. The cop was being a cock.
- topgun
- Approved FTO Australia Trader
- Posts: 327
- Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 10:24 pm
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
I agree!! Does the cop have a 'loud noise' monitor in his car!!Bennoz wrote:How the hell does a cop 'know' when an exhaust is too loud? Is his ear the DB measuring device? No. You'll have to take it to court.
Same with the speeding. They can't follow you for a 1/4 mile while checking your speed on their speedo. Doesn't work like that any more, must be gun measured.
If you can afford the time off work & want to beat the system, take itt to court cause you'll get off both items. The cop was being a cock.


"FTO stainless steel goodies!!!"
- brad_gpx
- Veteran Mechanic
- Posts: 1128
- Joined: Mon Aug 17, 2009 5:00 pm
- Location: central coast
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
Bennoz wrote:The cop was being a cock.
if he was a nice guy he wouldnt be cop

- Bennoz
- National President
- Posts: 23678
- Joined: Fri Jan 21, 2005 6:00 pm
- Location: Sydney
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
Well that's a P plater response if ever I've heard onebrad_gpx wrote:if he was a nice guy he wouldnt be copBennoz wrote:The cop was being a cock.

- Valandis91
- Veteran Mechanic
- Posts: 1169
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2008 5:00 pm
- Location: Tasmania
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
thats what im hoping for.spency wrote:by the time you take it to court and fight it, you may be on your next stage.
you should only be dropped back to restart p2s (hopefully)
The thing is im pretty sure it is too loud... but nothing has ever been said to me before...Bennoz wrote:How the hell does a cop 'know' when an exhaust is too loud? Is his ear the DB measuring device? No. You'll have to take it to court.
Same with the speeding. They can't follow you for a 1/4 mile while checking your speed on their speedo. Doesn't work like that any more, must be gun measured.
If you can afford the time off work & want to beat the system, take itt to court cause you'll get off both items. The cop was being a cock.
so whats my plan of defence how should i play this in court?
its definately going to the courts.
the cop even admitted owning 4 r32 skylines and knowing how your pretty much a target...

- BrendanT
- Apprentice
- Posts: 25
- Joined: Mon May 25, 2009 5:00 pm
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
Guarantee he is never hassled by his cop mates though...Valandis91 wrote: the cop even admitted owning 4 r32 skylines and knowing how your pretty much a target...
- topgun
- Approved FTO Australia Trader
- Posts: 327
- Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 10:24 pm
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
Unfortunately this is the society we are living in!
When it gets to court it's his word against yours... (on the speeding) who do you think the magistrates will believe?
It's not right & it's nowhere near fair but fighting a coppers word in court is virtually impossible.
Unless you have some "proof" you were not exceeding the limit it's not worth fighting. You could ask for his 'proof' !!!
A bag of shite I know.......some cops just have fcuk all better to do with their time!!!
When it gets to court it's his word against yours... (on the speeding) who do you think the magistrates will believe?
It's not right & it's nowhere near fair but fighting a coppers word in court is virtually impossible.
Unless you have some "proof" you were not exceeding the limit it's not worth fighting. You could ask for his 'proof' !!!
A bag of shite I know.......some cops just have fcuk all better to do with their time!!!

"FTO stainless steel goodies!!!"
- spency
- Mechanic
- Posts: 761
- Joined: Sun Mar 28, 2010 5:00 pm
- Location: Hobart
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
^ this.topgun wrote:Unfortunately this is the society we are living in!
When it gets to court it's his word against yours... (on the speeding) who do you think the magistrates will believe?
It's not right & it's nowhere near fair but fighting a coppers word in court is virtually impossible.
Unless you have some "proof" you were not exceeding the limit it's not worth fighting. You could ask for his 'proof' !!!
A bag of shite I know.......some cops just have fcuk all better to do with their time!!!
i got put into the "hoon" database 2 weeks ago for doing a fully sik burn0ut bruz. it was wet, uphill and i swear the wheels did 1 revolution. what made it worse was i was waiting for some mates that got stuck at traffic lights, a car had just passed me and i pulled out behind it.... f**kers
- bduffman
- Oldtimer
- Posts: 1450
- Joined: Sun Jan 31, 2010 6:00 pm
- Location: gosford
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
i got done the same sorta thing altho i was massively speeding but he couldnt prove it but he gave me a ticket any way
theres not much you can do altho if he said he was doing 70 to catch up and he caught u then how could you have been doing 70 ?
call the police station ask to see the video ( if they have one )
but its very likely you wont win police could pick any rego and say he was doing 30kms over the limit ( if they wanted ) and theres no way to prove you wernt
not unless you had a mangement that records your speed limit
ive been thinking bout throwing in some front and rear cameras and carputer plug it into ecu and record all data ( but then that might just get me a worse fine hahaha )
theres not much you can do altho if he said he was doing 70 to catch up and he caught u then how could you have been doing 70 ?
call the police station ask to see the video ( if they have one )
but its very likely you wont win police could pick any rego and say he was doing 30kms over the limit ( if they wanted ) and theres no way to prove you wernt
not unless you had a mangement that records your speed limit
ive been thinking bout throwing in some front and rear cameras and carputer plug it into ecu and record all data ( but then that might just get me a worse fine hahaha )
- bduffman
- Oldtimer
- Posts: 1450
- Joined: Sun Jan 31, 2010 6:00 pm
- Location: gosford
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
btw if you take it to court and its gone past the time you can get your p2s you wont be able to
rta has gotten smarter if there is a pending suspention then they wont let you upgrade
i lost my licence for 6 months ( didnt no at the time fine only said 3 )
so after 3 months went and payed got my licence back week later went to get my green ps
rta said no you cant your being suspended in a month they hadnt notified me at all when i got home i called up about it and they said yep we sent it out umm today i was like yea after i went in there
rta has gotten smarter if there is a pending suspention then they wont let you upgrade
i lost my licence for 6 months ( didnt no at the time fine only said 3 )
so after 3 months went and payed got my licence back week later went to get my green ps
rta said no you cant your being suspended in a month they hadnt notified me at all when i got home i called up about it and they said yep we sent it out umm today i was like yea after i went in there
- brad_gpx
- Veteran Mechanic
- Posts: 1128
- Joined: Mon Aug 17, 2009 5:00 pm
- Location: central coast
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
You know itBennoz wrote:Well that's a P plater response if ever I've heard onebrad_gpx wrote:if he was a nice guy he wouldnt be copBennoz wrote:The cop was being a cock.
- Valandis91
- Veteran Mechanic
- Posts: 1169
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2008 5:00 pm
- Location: Tasmania
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
went and spoke to the police today to see if i could get the infringement removed before taking it to court no deal.
i told thhem about the exhaust and he was like well youve probably been lucky and not been heard by anyone that knows the legislation.
and about the speeding apparently its called a pace check. such bullshit.
court it is.
oh its on
i told thhem about the exhaust and he was like well youve probably been lucky and not been heard by anyone that knows the legislation.
and about the speeding apparently its called a pace check. such bullshit.
court it is.
oh its on

- topgun
- Approved FTO Australia Trader
- Posts: 327
- Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 10:24 pm
- bduffman
- Oldtimer
- Posts: 1450
- Joined: Sun Jan 31, 2010 6:00 pm
- Location: gosford
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
They can only do a speed check on a stright traveling at the same speed for a certain distance
Corners are a bit diff as most people brake befor the corner and bit had to judge distance and speed on corners
I got done bout 1km away at night witth no street lights with another car between me and the cop
Mayb there robbocop
Corners are a bit diff as most people brake befor the corner and bit had to judge distance and speed on corners
I got done bout 1km away at night witth no street lights with another car between me and the cop
Mayb there robbocop
- KJ_bob
- Mechanic
- Posts: 445
- Joined: Wed Jun 04, 2008 5:00 pm
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
Some of you guys are forgetting that each state has different road laws and enforcement. RTA is nsw.
I would be going to court and basically arguing that a police officer is not a calibrated/accurate measuring device
I would be going to court and basically arguing that a police officer is not a calibrated/accurate measuring device
- spency
- Mechanic
- Posts: 761
- Joined: Sun Mar 28, 2010 5:00 pm
- Location: Hobart
- Contact:
Re: Got minor defect notice, sigh
i beg to differ.KJ_bob wrote:Some of you guys are forgetting that each state has different road laws and enforcement. RTA is nsw.
I would be going to court and basically arguing that a police officer is not a calibrated/accurate measuring device
they can calculate what it takes to piss people off quite accuraltly.